Raph Mokades, founder and managing director of Rare.
The founder of diversity recruiter Rare has called on the government to replace the current style of unconscious bias training in the civil service with a more targeted and data-driven training regime.
Rare founder Raph Mokades made the call after unconscious bias training in Whitehall was abruptly scrapped last week. He agreed that a lot of bias training was not effective but more modern methods should replace them.
He said that the real issue was that commonly used training techniques did not produce sustained results: “The government has argued that unconscious bias training doesn’t work, because it doesn’t lead to positive or lasting changes of behaviour,” had said. “Our research suggests that’s true of traditional training. Such training isn’t industry – or organisation – specific, and usually takes place as a one-off, box-ticking exercise.
“There is another way, however. Data-driven exercises, based upon context-specific experiences of an organisation’s own people, offering confidential, personalised action points for each user – this is a different proposition from generic feel-bad blanket training.”
He added that Rare’s Hemisphere software, being rolled out with several City institutions, was already proving this point among the firm’s clients.
“The government has said it is still committed to eradicating workplace discrimination in the civil service. It is vital that it stays true to that promise. We know, from the thousands of young people we have placed into even the most high-powered and forward-looking employers, that bias exists, that it damages an organisation’s performance, and creates injustices that can be devastating.”
More hi-tech, data driven software was far more effective than more traditional training, he said.
For example, Hemisphere asks participants to score clips from interviews of real candidates, who were in the process of applying to real firms at the time of their interviews. The software doesn’t use a proxy to measure bias, it uses the differences between the way users react to people when they can see and hear them and when they can’t. It then lets the individual user know what their biases are. The specificity of the training increases its validity and reliability.
The software has been developed over a five-year period, with qualitative and quantitative feedback analysed from City firms. The project was overseen by Dr Lara Zibarras, senior lecturer in the Organisational Psychology Group, at City University.
Dr Zibarras said: “Hemisphere is very context specific. It makes you question whether you are rating people on whether they can do the job or on some sort of unconscious bias. Hemisphere looks at gender, ethnicity and socio-economic status.
She added that the software made people question for themselves whether they were rating people in the correct way – on whether they could do the job.
Rare introduces talented ethnic-minority candidates to a range of top-tier employers, and also runs the Target Oxbridge university access programme.
Hemisphere has launched with Ashurst, Blackrock, Clifford Chance, DC Advisory, Freshfields and Herbert Smith Freehills.